Susan Smith wants another chance at life. Her two little boys, whom she murdered in 1994, never got that opportunity.

On Thursday, a South Carolina parole board unanimously rejected Smith’s second request for freedom, keeping the convicted child killer behind bars. You can watch the hearing here. But be warned. It’s difficult to get through.

Smith, 55, drowned her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, by rolling her car into a lake while they were strapped into their car seats. She then spent nine days pretending a Black carjacker had kidnapped them.

Smith apologized during Thursday’s hearing, insisting she’s changed. Her ex-husband, David Smith, who had a photo of his two children pinned to his suit, wasn’t buying it. He reminded board members that his sons’ deaths were deliberate.

The poor guy has to show up at Susan’s parole hearing every two years, relive the nightmare of losing his children, and endure the anxiety of knowing Susan could someday walk free. He also has to listen to Susan blather on about being “sorry” and saying she’s changed and asking for her freedom.

If you watch the hearing, the contrast is heartbreaking. David is visibly overcome with grief, crying as he speaks about his murdered children and continuing to wipe away tears throughout the proceedings. Susan, however, did not cry for her children. It’s unconscionable that this grieving father is put in the position of having to BEG the parole board to keep his children’s killer behind bars. “Please,” he says twice, pleading with the board not to release her. A father should never have to beg for that kind of justice.

Do you support individual military members being able to opt out of getting the COVID vaccine?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from SteveGruber.com, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

His current wife Tiffany said at the hearing: “Every time we must come before this board, it forces us to reopen wounds that have never really healed. We must revisit the worst tragedy of our lives and once again ask that the person responsible remain in prison.”

The boys’ aunt was also in tears as she spoke, comparing the ordeal of attending the parole hearing to ripping off a Band-Aid and reopening old wounds. Even Tiffany and David’s daughter, who never had the chance to meet her two brothers, broke down as she described the devastating impact their murders have had on her family. The grief has carried through generations, affecting even those who never knew the boys.

Tommy Pope, the former prosecutor who helped convict Smith of murdering her two young sons and who now serves as Speaker Pro Tempore of the South Carolina House, also addressed the parole board. “In some ways I think today is harder than the trial was,” he said, prompting David and his wife to nod in agreement. Pope also warned that an attention-seeking Smith would likely embrace social media and thrust herself back into the spotlight if released, forcing the boys’ grieving family to see her face plastered across their phones and social media feeds – a cruel reminder of the woman who took their children’s lives.

Kevin Brackett, the current solicitor for South Carolina’s 16th Judicial Circuit who previously served as Tommy Pope’s deputy, also addressed the parole board. Brackett recalled being at the lake when authorities pulled Smith’s car from the water, a painful memory that brought David to tears once again. Brackett described David as still being a “ball of grief” and emphasized the cruelty of forcing a father who has already endured unimaginable loss to repeatedly relive his children’s murders at parole hearings.

Brackett also agreed that Smith would likely try to monetize her sons’ murders if released, pointing to her reported contact with a media person over the past two years. Several other law enforcement officials also addressed the parole board, reminding members that Smith’s crimes went far beyond murdering her two young sons. She lied about what happened, falsely accused a Black man of kidnapping them and sent law enforcement on a massive nine-day search – all while knowing exactly where her children were and what she had done to them.

Susan’s parole hearings started in 2024 and will go on and on and on…David has vowed to attend every single one, determined to keep his children’s killer behind bars. But it’s outrageous that a grieving father must spend the rest of his life fighting to make sure the woman who murdered his sons stays in prison. He told PEOPLE: “I’m totally against [Susan’s release] and I want [the parole board] to see, I guess, the pain and the hurt that I still have. I want them to see that in my face. I want them to hear in my voice. I want them to look at me when I talk to them and feel all that, and know that 32 years is nothing for me. It might be 32 years for them has gone by, but to me, it’s still like yesterday.”

Smith will get another shot at getting out of prison in 2028 due to the state’s parole law – a law that gives convicted killers repeated chances at freedom. But Michael and Alex will never get another birthday, another Christmas or another chance at life. Their mother made sure of that.

Susan’s defense attorneys argued that she was suicidal, severely depressed and emotionally disturbed when she drove her car into a lake with her two young sons strapped inside. Her attorneys also maintained that she intended to kill herself along with her children. Sound familiar??

Because Smith’s case isn’t the only one raising painful questions about justice for children killed by their own mothers. Another (accused) child killer – Massachusetts mother Lindsay Clancy – who investigators say killed her three children in 2023, remains unconvicted after a mistrial. Her defense argues she was not criminally responsible because of mental illness. A retrial is scheduled for March 2027.

Different cases, similar legal arguments. But five children are dead. At least on Thursday, justice prevailed for two of those children.