For decades, the international answer to Haiti’s troubles was more aid, more NGOs, more U.N. missions and more patience. Then President Jovenel Moïse was assassinated in his own home, gangs tightened their grip on Port-au-Prince, and nearly 1.5 million Haitians were driven from their homes. After four Salvadoran aviation technicians disappeared in an October 18 gang ambush, El Salvador’s president, Nayib Bukele, sent troops to find them.
Bukele had already laid out his approach at home over the summer. His crackdown brought a dramatic drop in El Salvador’s homicide rate and drew criticism over mass detention and due process. The principle he took to Haiti was simple. Protecting people from the gangs that prey on them is a basic job of government.
The four missing technicians had been serving with the U.N.-backed Gang Suppression Force. Haiti’s government agreed to the Salvadoran troop surge, and Bukele said El Salvador was covering 90 percent of the cost. The immediate mission was to bring his people home. As of November 18, the four were still missing.
MORE NEWS: Detroit Pistons Make Room for Muslim Night Thanksgiving Weekend, With Hats, Hoops and Halal Food
Bukele said his forces destroyed the home of 400 Mawozo leader Wilson Joseph and the gang’s headquarters. He said most of the gang members fled. On November 18, he announced a separate strike on the home of another powerful gang leader known as Jeff. For men who had grown accustomed to ruling their territory with impunity, that was a change.
The response in Port-au-Prince was worth hearing. Thousands marched on consecutive days in support of Bukele and the Salvadoran troops. For the Haitians who took to the streets, the demonstrations were a chance to say plainly what they wanted after years of gang rule. They wanted their neighborhoods back.
Protecting civilians and holding territory are the tests that come next. Anyone can count the buildings brought down. The numbers worth watching are how many families can go home, how many children can get to school and how many shopkeepers can open without paying a gang for permission.
A Salvadoran security adviser and political analyst argues that Bukele’s forces accomplished more against the gangs in weeks than years of international intervention. He also makes a broader charge about foreign aid in Haiti and who ultimately benefited from it. His argument raises a question that donors ought to answer. After years of spending, what changed for the people the money was supposed to help?
That question belongs in the debate over USAID, too. The Trump administration shifted the agency’s remaining foreign assistance functions to the State Department. The people who lived with the results of those programs deserve a say in what comes next.
A former African Union ambassador to the United States makes a similar case about the aid industry across the developing world. Organizations arrive promising grassroots help, she argues, while the people they came to serve are left asking where the money went and what it bought for their schools and clinics.
Emergency aid can keep people alive. An aid system should also be able to show how its work helps communities need less emergency aid over time. In April, Secretary of State Marco Rubio pushed for a “trade over aid” declaration, putting the administration’s argument for a different U.S. approach before other governments.
President Trump took a similarly direct line in his conversation with Bukele. When the Salvadoran president described the crisis in Haiti, Trump told him, “You have to do what you have to do.”
Meanwhile, Wilson Joseph, the leader of 400 Mawozo, told the Associated Press he had asked the United Nations to send a delegation for talks. A gang leader knew exactly where to send a letter when he wanted a hearing. The families forced out of their neighborhoods have been waiting years for theirs.
Haiti’s recovery starts on the street where a parent has to decide whether it’s safe to send a child to school. It starts at the shop that can open without an extortion payment and with the family that can finally go home. Those are the results Haitians have every right to demand from Bukele, their own government and every institution that has spent years promising relief.
Haitians have heard enough about how much was spent. They ought to be able to walk home and see what it bought.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.