New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has a new approach to handling potentially violent protesters: less police muscle and more friendly conversation. What could possibly go wrong?
Mamdani, who is Muslim, is eliminating [1] the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG), a specialized unit trained to handle terrorist threats, violent demonstrations, active shooters and other major emergencies. But now, things are changing. In its place is the following…
The Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division (CDDD) will be made up of unarmed civilian teams, not police officers. Its job will be to communicate with protesters and help prevent confrontations. Members will not carry weapons or have the power to arrest anyone. Yes, you read that right. Civilian-led teams. And, yes, this is not a joke.
There will also be the First Amendment Support Team (FAST) which will consist of 30 uniformed NYPD officers specially trained to communicate with protesters, ease tensions and prevent conflicts. They will work closely with the civilian team. Wow. 30 officers in a city of 8.5 million. Sounds like an excellent plan.
Then there’s the Patrol Support Division (PSD), which will consist of NYPD officers who primarily perform regular patrol duties but receive additional training in crowd control. They’ll be called upon to help manage demonstrations when needed. Called on by whom? And most likely called when it’s too late and things have already spiraled out of control.
The mayor’s supporters argue that the SRG has been too aggressive toward demonstrators. By demonstrators, he means violent criminals who are prone to hurt people and police.
However, critics worry that dismantling a specialized unit could weaken the city’s emergency response capabilities.
Ticked off Patrick Hendry, who is president of the Police Benevolent Association, said, “Today is not a good day for New Yorkers who just want a safe and orderly city.”
Counterterrorism responsibilities will be transferred to the NYPD’s existing Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau, so those operations aren’t disappearing entirely. But dismantling a specialized unit focused on identifying potential terrorist threats will most likely leave dangerous gaps in intelligence gathering. In a city that remains a prime terrorist target, those are gaps New York can ill afford.
And with the NYPD already operating with fewer officers than it had six years ago, dismantling a specialized counterterrorism and rapid-response unit is not a good idea.
The message from City Hall seems clear: Make protesters more comfortable and hope the dangerous ones cooperate.