- Steve Gruber - https://www.stevegruber.com -

America Is Temporarily Unavailable

On Nov. 17, the National Security Agency’s classified internal communications network went down. The NSA said the disruption occurred during scheduled maintenance and that mission-critical operations continued. People familiar with the outage told CNN there was no evidence of a cyberattack.

Take that explanation at face value for a moment. An agency charged with protecting some of America’s most sensitive information lost access to an internal network while doing the work required to keep it running. How much room for error do the rest of our systems have?

The past week gave us a few answers. Microsoft users had trouble accessing email and collaboration tools. JPMorgan Chase reported problems processing some transactions. An internal outage delayed United Airlines departures. And on Nov. 13, a network disruption prompted the Federal Aviation Administration to order a nationwide ground stop, delaying or canceling thousands of flights.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy pointed to a router installation during an equipment upgrade. The FAA identified two sites as possible sources of the network overload and said it was still investigating the root cause.

People I’ve talked to are skeptical. They’ve heard the explanations, and they want to know how a routine equipment change could bring departures across the country to a halt. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin told Fox News he was highly confident the disruptions he was asked about weren’t the work of cyberattackers and said the banking system remained secure.

Officials owe the public enough detail to make sense of what happened. Sen. Josh Hawley of Missouri questioned whether the outages were a coincidence and called for a full Senate briefing and public answers.

Aging equipment and hidden software defects can do plenty of damage on their own. Consider what a few hours of downtime can mean. A payment sits in limbo. A flight crew can’t get where it needs to be. An office loses the tools it uses to get through the day. For much of American life, the internet has become the operating system.

A cybersecurity expert warns that the coming months could bring more disruption as organizations race to protect those systems against faster-moving threats.

A separate FBI alert gave that warning some urgency. The bureau documented real intrusions in which attackers used artificial intelligence to gain elevated access in under three hours. In another incident, Norwegian energy company Equinor disclosed an attack on some of its IT systems on Nov. 17. The company said oil and gas production continued.

AI can also help defenders detect and respond to threats faster. A former NSA official argues that organizations will need AI-enabled defenses of their own to keep up.

Speed creates its own problem. How much time do engineers have to test an update before pushing it into a system millions of people depend on? And when those systems fail, who gets more authority to decide what happens next? That’s the question I’m listening for in this clip from Bill Gates.

When people are rattled, the people promising to restore order have an easier time asking for more power. That deserves scrutiny, especially when there are real threats to respond to. As Sen. John Kennedy puts it, there will always be people looking to raise “fresh hell.”

The FAA’s investigation may ultimately trace the ground stop to ordinary equipment work. The NSA’s outage may come down to the difficulty of maintaining a complex network. Both incidents raise a question worth answering now. How much of daily life can carry on while the systems we depend on are being repaired?

The next update is already on the calendar. The time to find out whether the backup works is before we need it.